We opened this semester reading John Berger's Ways of Seeing. I think this opening video clip from his BBC series does a good job summing up the book as a whole. The book raises questions about the deeper meaning behind visual images. His essay also looks at how western ideology has shaped the way we interpret images and define the "fine arts."
I find it very interesting how the term "fine art" doesn't exactly recognize artwork made by native culture. Civilizations\areas which dominate the art world are Europe (obviously), Japan, China, the middle east, and Egypt.
Ragnar Johnson's essay
Accumulation and Collecting: An Anthropological Perspective looks at traditional practices in art collecting. This essay is a direct criticism to another essay written on fine art collecting called
The Rare Art Traditions written by
Joseph Alsop. Alsop writes "Art collecting approximating that practiced in institutionalized sense in contemporary western society has only ever occurred in complex, highly stratified literate societies where where it is restricted to its wealthy elite..." Alsop also writes about the importance of provenance associated with fine art which "obviously" couldn't exist in a native culture.
Johnson uses the example of
Kula Rings made, collected, and passed down by natives in the Trobriand Islands off of Papua New Guinea, the following clip shows how this tradition meets the standards of what Alsop considers art, which at the same time makes his essay rather meaningless.
There is no embed code for this video here is the
link. I recommend watching the section at 7:24 and 44:19